Each girls prep hockey season is its own beast, but you can always count on plenty of parity and talent around the NEPSAC in any given winter.
It would be too simple to say the last two seasons were all about Loomis Chaffee.
Don’t you remember how dominant Nobles was in the regular season? How about Phillips Exeter’s super line or New Hampton’s Cinderella run to the Small School final? What about how close the race for the final Large School tournament spot was?
There is never a shortage of storylines to dissect. While many will reveal themselves as we go along, here are 10 to watch before the puck drops on the 2026-27 season.
1. Can Loomis Chaffee three-peat?
Winning one championship is never easy, let alone two in a row. But three in a row? That’s certainly a tall task.
Few teams have accomplished such a feat. Nobles was the last to do it in the top bracket, winning three straight Division 1 titles from 2008 to 2010. New Hampton was the last to do it in any capacity, with three Small School crowns in a row from 2023 to 2025. Governor’s also won four consecutive Division 2 titles from 2008 to 2011.
TOP 10: Who led our preseason girls prep rankings?
If anyone else could do it, why not Loomis? Sure, the Pelicans graduated eight seniors, including several foundational pieces to their back-to-back Elite 8 titles. But there is a stable of experienced returners and new cornerstones at every position who have the skill to make Loomis a contender once again.
2. Can anyone in the ISL challenge Nobles?
Count Nobles among the preseason favorites, as the Bulldogs boast high-end skill and depth at every position. But the games aren’t played on paper. Who else could contend in the ISL?
Tabor is one group that will get plenty of attention. The Seawolves have a top-flight goaltender in Evelyn Lacey (Braintree, Mass.), in addition to talented forwards like Sofia Nardelli (Cranston, R.I.) and Giuliana Polcari (Marshfield, Mass.).
There’s also Rivers. The Red Wings have been knocking on the door in recent seasons, and a deep group of upperclassmen that includes Simone Burns (Winchester, Mass.), Brooke Bartlett (Wayland, Mass.), Mia MacDonald (Walpole, Mass.) and Nora Swaim (Concord, Mass.) may be ready to ascend.
NEXT 15: Who opens the season at Nos. 11-25 in our girls prep rankings?
Last year’s Small School champion Groton will remain a factor, while BB&N is another to watch. The Knights exceeded expectations last season, and goalie Barbara Ma (Cambridge, Mass.) will again give them a chance every night. Youngsters like Serena Mohsen (Newton, Mass.), Cali Littlewood (Braintree, Mass.) and Janvi Singh (Lexington, Mass.) have plenty of promise.
Don’t forget about Thayer with stars like Maddy Call (Dedham, Mass.) and Lydia Kealty (Norfolk, Mass.) in addition to a strong supporting cast.
3. What is Phillips Andover’s ceiling?
Andover is in an interesting spot.
The Big Blue had one of the highest-powered offenses last season, but this time around, their biggest strengths may be defense and goaltending.
After graduating some of the best forwards in prep and bringing in Kate Leary as coach, the Big Blue return one of the deepest blue lines in the NEPSAC and one of the best goalies.
There are promising young players up front who, if they pop, may take Andover from a contender to a favorite.
4. Can St. Paul’s contend for a title?
St. Paul’s is a fascinating team to watch.
The Big Red could score with the best of them last season, ranking second in goals-for en route to a second Elite 8 appearance in three seasons. While they graduated a handful of key pieces, SPS returns elite skill throughout the lineup.
You’ve got Erin Flaherty (Boston, Mass.; Boston University) and Kelsey MacPherson (Hopkinton, Mass.) headlining a deep forward group that also includes Brown commit Maddy Allen and Merrimack commit Cadence Crowley (North Reading, Mass.). SPS shouldn’t have any issues putting the puck in the back of the net again.
BOYS PREP RANKINGS: Who leads the top 10? | Who made the Next 15?
On the back end, Yale commit Maddy Humber (Concord, Mass.) leads a young blue line alongside promising sophomore Malin Wilde (Shelburne, Vt.). Hamilton commit Paige MacPhee and Julia Alessandro give the Big Red two quality goaltenders.
It could be a recipe for SPS to take the next step to contend.
5. Can Phillips Exeter, Groton crack the Elite 8?
It’s a question we ask of the reigning Large and Small School champions entering each new season. Can they take the next step and contend in the Elite 8?
Deerfield did that last winter. After winning the Large School title in 2025, the Big Green reached the Elite 8 finals the following year. BB&N did something similar the season prior: it won the Large School title in 2024 and reached the Elite 8 semis in 2025. Dexter Southfield, the 2024 Large runner-up, has made the last two Elite 8 fields.
It’s been a different story in the Small bracket, as New Hampton won three straight titles before making a fourth straight final in 2026. However, 2024 runner-up Groton made the Elite 8 in 2025.
Whether or not there are direct correlations to any of the above is anyone’s guess, but it’s safe to expect Exeter and Groton in the mix for Elite 8 seeding in 2026-27. Both squads graduated cornerstones from last season’s winners, but both have supplanted tentpole returners with rising youngsters ready to take the next steps.
6. Which other non-Elite 8 teams will have a shot at the top bracket?
Beyond reigning champs like Exeter and Groton, several other Large and Small School tournament contenders from last season are likely to push for the Elite 8.
There are, of course, aforementioned teams like Thayer, Rivers, New Hampton and BB&N. Expect each to be in the hunt.
GIRLS PREP PREVIEWS: Phillips Exeter |Â Taft |Â Loomis Chaffee | Groton | Phillips Andover | Brooks
One team that immediately sticks out? Cushing.
The Penguins had some ups, downs and unlucky injuries at different points last season. But Cushing had and still has the roster to be an Elite 8 contender. Bella Freitas (Everett, Mass.) figures to remain a potent offensive threat, while there’s key experience among the forwards and especially on a blue line with six upperclassmen.
Keep an eye on Taft, St. Mark’s and Governor’s, too. Taft and St. Mark’s boast young cores that showed plenty of potential last season, and they could continue their ascent this winter. Governor’s, meanwhile, has talented upperclassmen both at forward and on defense.
7. Which non-playoff teams could make it this year?
Along similar lines, which teams that missed the postseason in 2026 might be in the mix this time around?
A few stand out right away.
Hoosac and St. George’s each barely missed the Small School field. The former should remain a factor with returning producers like Sarah Lawson and Mackenzie Richardson. The latter returns consistent contributors like Carah Ford (York, Maine) and Sophie Procaccini (Walpole, Mass.).
Others to watch include Brooks for the Small School bracket, which boasts a burgeoning core of Natasha Godfrey (Scarborough, Maine), Shelby Buckler (Sherborn, Mass.), and Cassie Ling (Needham, Mass.), along with goalie Ella Puleo (Newburyport, Mass.).
MAKING THE JUMP: Former girls prep stars on going from prep to college hockey
Holderness is fascinating, too, after adding Adia Murphy (Dedham, Mass.) and Kayleigh Norton (Pelham, N.H.), who previously lit up the scoresheet at Austin Prep. Elizabeth Maher (New London, N.H.) is a key returner who has had a strong fall, while top scorer Lexi Morris (Bedford, N.H.) returns.
There’s Westminster in the Large School as well. The Martlets have strong goaltending in Liesel Kocourek, plus talented forwards like Bella Zapata and Mya Polastry (West Springfield, Mass.).
8. Who will win the scoring race?
Last season featured a plethora of high-flying scorers in the hunt for the scoring crown. Five players eclipsed the 50-point threshold, while six more reached 40 points. Safe to say, the NEPSAC was not short on offense.
In the end, Nobles’ Francie Ames (Brookline, Mass.) ran away with it, finishing with 65 points in 30 games. Her 26 goals were second to Exeter’s Paisley Meyer (Greenland, N.H.), whose 56 points were the second-most.
Ames’ teammate Lily Bromley (Carlisle, Mass.) is likely to be a factor, following a 37-point season. Meyer’s Exeter counterpart, Erin Sears (Cornwall, Vt.), also had 37 points.
Among the other top returning scorers, keep an eye on Cushing’s Freitas, who had 23 goals and 31 points a year after cracking the 40-point mark. Thayer’s Call had a huge year with 43 points (24 goals), while St. Paul’s Flaherty had 39 points (26 goals). Her teammate, MacPherson, could have a shot after 26 points in 20 games as a freshman.
BOYS PREP PREVIEWS: Brunswick | Winchendon | Cushing | Salisbury | Kimball Union | Hotchkiss | Williston | Taft | Holderness | Phillips Exeter | Dexter Southfield | St. Paul’s
New Hampton’s Emma MacPherson (Scituate, Mass.) was a force, too, exploding for 39 points in 31 games. Meanwhile, Brooke Carlson (North Andover, Mass.) has put up back-to-back 30-point seasons at Gov’s.
As for players who could establish themselves among the above group this season? Look out for Loomis Chaffee sophomore Lexi Buco (North Providence, R.I.). She had 16 points as a freshman at Loomis, but the year prior, she posted 32 points in 22 games at Mount St. Charles.
9. Who will be the best goalie?
Just as prep wasn’t short on offense last season, it wasn’t short on stout goaltending either.
Tabor’s Lacey was arguably the best NEPSAC goalie last season, and that should remain the case. The Brown commit posted a .954 save percentage and stole several games for the Seawolves.
Yale commit Annika Jonas (Weston, Mass.) has been spectacular at Nobles over the last two seasons with back-to-back .950 markers. You’ve also got Marie Lee (Southboro, Mass.), a Princeton commit who had a .921 for Andover last winter.
Ma will be BB&N’s bedrock once again. She had a .932 save percentage. Groton will lean on Wilson again, too. The Dartmouth commit had a .944 save percentage and was outstanding in the postseason. Keep an eye on Middlesex’s Niamh Tobin (Dorchester, Mass.), too, who had a .939 save percentage.
NEGHL CLASH: 9 uncommitted 19U standouts from Assabet vs. Conn. Polar Bears
Other names to watch include Loomis’ Emily Hosman (.982 save percentage), Pomfret’s Sydney Kelm (.937), Tilton’s Madelyn Andrade (Plymouth, Mass.; .937), Proctor’s Katie Grady (.930) and Portsmouth Abbey’s Marguerite Cordahi (.951).
10. Familiar faces in new places
Each year a smattering of transfers and postgraduates move to, and around, the NEPSAC. Who are some to watch this winter?
There’s Janie Martin (Burlington, Mass.) at Cushing. After a standout career at Middlesex, which included three straight 20-point seasons and 37 goals over the last two, the Assumption commit will add even more punch to Cushing’s offense.
Williston is adding two impact upperclassmen in defender Olivia Bonarrigo (Walpole, Mass.) and forward Molly Bardol (Walpole, Mass.). Bonarrigo, a Stonehill commit, was a standout at NAHA over the last three seasons. Bardol, meanwhile, posted 17 points as a sophomore at Cushing, following an 18-point freshman year.
Defender Raven Bennett (Morris, Conn.) will join Taft, strengthening a blue line that includes Phoebe Weisman and Kami Moors (Simsbury, Conn.). Bennett broke out with 24 points (13 goals) at Frederick Gunn last season. She and Moors have frequently played together on a pair with Mid Fairfield.
Millbrook added Courtney Shifrin (Southboro, Mass.) as well. Shifrin, an Assumption commit, was an impact power forward at Lawrence Academy over the last two seasons.
Ani Andersen, who spent last season at Winsor, could be an impact youngster at Exeter, too.


