Stop me if you’ve heard this before, but this might be one of the deepest preseason landscapes I can remember in my time covering girls prep hockey.
Yes, it’s something we seemingly call out every year, but this season, we really mean it.
As I compiled my preseason top 25, I could’ve made cases for at least 17 teams to crack the top 10. And I could’ve come up with at least 30 or so with cases for the top 25.
Safe to say, there was some paralysis by analysis. But the beauty of it is the games aren’t played on paper, so it’s fair to expect these rankings to be jumbled in a blender as soon as the puck drops on 2026-27.
In just a few weeks, I doubt our top 10 will resemble the rankings below.
Many of last season’s contenders will be prevalent factors once again, while some sleeper teams could emerge.
Let’s dive in.
1. Nobles
2025-26 record: 28-2-0; lost Elite 8 semifinals to Loomis Chaffee
The Bulldogs, last season’s No. 1 seed, lost some key pieces, but Tom Resor’s group is still loaded. Up front, there’s Princeton commits Francie Ames and Lily Bromley, while Penn State commit Catherine McCool could provide a boost upon her return from injury. Defense will be a strength for Nobles, too, with the likes of Ava Decourcey (Yale), Reese Engel (Princeton) and Nora Shea (Dartmouth), in addition to young risers like Liz Levering and Parker Kathan. Goalie Annika Jonas (Yale) is among the best in prep, too. Keep an eye on young newcomers Juliet Platt and Hanley Finnicum as well.
BOYS PREP RANKINGS: Who leads the top 10? | Who made the Next 15?
2. Loomis Chaffee
2025-26 record: 24-4-0; won Elite 8 championship over Deerfield
While the Pelicans graduated several stalwarts from a group that won back-to-back titles, they’re still in a position to contend with the next core emerging. Liz Leyden’s squad boasts experience up front with Easton Pramuka (Amherst) and Brooke Murphy (Colby), as well as Alexine Beaulieu (RPI) and Lizzie Orszulak (Yale soccer) on the back end. Juniors Amaya McNeil (Holy Cross) and Mia Lynch lead the next wave on the blue line, while sophomores Lexi Buco, Sophie DiGioia and Scarlett Robertson could take the reins up front. Junior goalie Emily Hosman is poised to step into the starting role as well. Bess Elkins and June Kleiner are high-end newcomers to know.
3. Phillips Andover
2025-26 record: 21-3-1; lost Elite 8 quarterfinals to Tabor
Andover will have a new look this season with a young forward group and a new voice behind the bench in Kate Leary. But the Big Blue still have all the tools to compete. You’d be hard-pressed to find a deeper blue line, as Andover boasts Maggie Averill (Princeton), Kimee Duplessis (Delaware), Sienna Glass (Providence), Sienna DeAngelis (Amherst) and Maya Kou (Brown), in addition to Vanessa Hall and Jacqueline Louie. Princeton commit goalie Marie Lee will give them a chance every game in the crease, too. Promising young forwards like Katherine Cooke, Avery Hutchins, Al Hartmann and Liz Averill could run with more opportunity.
4. Williston Northampton
2025-26 record: 19-4-0; lost Elite 8 quarterfinals to Deerfield
Williston will also have a slightly different look after some key departures, but the Wildcats boast some new faces and emerging forces that will keep them in contention under Christa Talbot Syfu. Former NAHA defender Olivia Bonarrigo (Stonehill) and Cushing forward Molly Bardol could fit right in alongside forwards Mia Daley (Yale), Ava Carr (Merrimack) and Riley Stocker (Merrimack), as well as defender Keira Gould (Boston University). Younger skaters Ashley Anderson, Sam Sada, Caitlyn Byrne and Amelia Paes could provide boosts, too. In the crease, River Grady (Bowdoin) and Olivia Arsenault each have experience.
GIRLS PREP PREVIEWS: Phillips Exeter |Â Taft |Â Loomis Chaffee | Groton | Phillips Andover | Brooks
5. St. Paul’s
2025-26 record: 21-6-3, lost Elite 8 quarterfinals to Nobles
The Big Red return much of what was one of the NEPSAC's most high-powered offenses last season. Kelli Mackey’s group will rely on Erin Flaherty (BU) up front, as well as Kelsey MacPherson, Maddy Allen (Brown), Liza Demain and Cadence Crowley (Merrimack). On the back end, Maddy Humber (Yale) paces a stable of youngsters, including Malin Wilde and Emma Burke. Keep an eye on newcomers Caroline Warrington, Chatham Brouillette and Ava Franus as well. Meanwhile, goalies Paige MacPhee (Hamilton) and Julia Alessandro give SPS two good options, too.
6. Tabor
2025-26 record: 18-7-2; lost Elite 8 semifinals to Deerfield
The Seawolves lost a good amount of experience, but they boast plenty of talent at the top of the lineup, especially in goal with Evelyn Lacey (Brown), who will give Eric Long’s group a shot in any game. Up front, upperclassmen Giuliana Polcari (Northeastern), Sofia Nardelii (Merrimack) and Grace Hildebrandt will lead the way alongside Dawson Styles and Genevieve Smart. Experienced blue-liners Lindsay Fox, Riley Pike and Adeline Wiesel will be key on the back end, as will Layla Smart. Incoming forward Georgia Murray and defender Sophia Paone (Sacred Heart) could play key roles right away.
7. Cushing
2025-26 record: 14-10-4; lost Small School semifinals to New Hampton
The Penguins also graduated some high-end experience, but Brandy Fisher-Bailey’s team brings back some high-end forwards to go along with a deep blue line. Bella Freitas (Yale), one of prep’s best scorers, will pace the forwards along with Janie Martin (Assumption), Violet Dittman (Colby) and Brooke Fallon. The back end features six upperclassmen, too, including Emersyn Fisher-Bailey (UNH), Blake Metcalf and Caroline Harrington. Stella Hunter and Hayden Printz offer versatility as well. The question mark is in net. Ines Khamis and Lucy Holliday have experience, while Kiera Brindle enters the mix.
8. Dexter Southfield
2025-26 record: 20-3-2; lost Elite 8 quarterfinals to Loomis Chaffee
Dexter has reached back-to-back Elite 8s, and the Shields should be in the mix again with a skilled mix of youth and experience. Defender Maggie Chudzinski (Harvard) should be a force in every situation for Maggie Taverna’s team, while fellow blue-liner Chloe Rabazzi will also be key. Dexter will also be able to rely on senior goalie Annabelle Aitken (Middlebury). Up front, Leah Hafer (Dartmouth) broke out last season and returns alongside Devon Moore (Holy Cross), Teagan Beigel, Stella Walsh and Elena Gordon. Youngster Abby Loring could be primed to break out, too.
9. Rivers
2025-26 record: 14-8-2; lost Small School quarterfinals to New Hampton
The Red Wings were on the cusp of the Elite 8 last season before settling into a high seed in the Small School tournament. Keith McLean’s group could contend for the top tournament again with a deep, experienced forward group that includes Simone Burns (Yale), Brooke Bartlett (Harvard) and Nora Swaim, in addition to emerging contributors like Kendra Snell and Maggie Grant. On the blue line, a clean bill of health for Mia MacDonald (Dartmouth) is big, as she leads the way alongside Joelle Burns, Lyla DiPietro and Kathryn Butkus. Former MIAA standout Mia Cataruzolo is a key add as well. In net, the Red Wings could look to Avery Wightman and Elise Holland.
10. BB&N
2025-26 record: 12-12-3; lost Large School semifinals to Phillips Exeter
The Knights remained a playoff team last season even after graduating a handful of Division 1 commits. While Jori Balsam’s group graduated its leading scorer, BB&N is well-equipped to handle it with returning forwards in seniors Molly Halloran (Holy Cross), Kate Glantz (Brown) and Mary Murray (Middlebury), plus breakout candidates like Cali Littlewood. There’s experience on the blue line too with Aislin VanVliet and Chloe Crabtree, plus emerging underclassmen Serena Mohsen and Janvi Singh. Senior goalie Barbara Ma is coming off a standout junior season as well. Former MIAA standout Molly Whittier could add some scoring punch up front.
MAKING THE JUMP: Former girls prep stars on going from prep to college hockey


