We’ve unveiled the preseason top 10 teams in New England girls prep hockey. Now, it’s time to look at the next 15 best teams — spots No. 11 through 25.
One thing I wrote in our top 10: this is one of the deepest preseason landscapes I can remember over the last few seasons. Many of the teams below had cases to make for the top 10. Several others that didn't make the top 25 had cases for being ranked, too.
It's all but certain that our midseason top 25 will hardly resemble what it looks like now.
Below, you've got teams that have been mainstays in the Elite 8 hunt and general playoff picture in recent seasons, while others are in search of bounce-back seasons. You also have some teams that are on the rise.
Let's dive in.
11. Groton
2025-26 record: 19-6-4; won Small School championship over New Hampton
Speaking of new looks, Groton is entering a new era after graduating foundational parts of last season’s Small School winner. But Tim LeRoy’s next core has already shown signs of taking the next step. Ava Barbour, Charlotte Matusovich and Zoe Smith will take the reins up front, while Tatum Friedholm (Williams) and Caroline Matusovich will lead a young blue line. The biggest piece of it all is in net with Nora Wilson (Dartmouth), coming off a sensational junior year. Keep an eye on young defenders Anna Morello and Elaine Wu as well.
TOP 10: Who led our preseason girls prep rankings?
12. St. Mark’s
2025-26 record: 12-9-4; lost Small School semifinals to Groton
The Lions are full of promise and poised to take a step with a stable of returners who have previously impressed as underclassmen. Each of Kerstin Matthews’ top seven scorers from last season returns, with forwards Allie Sauls, Jocelyn Gray, Caroline Kreuz (Stonehill), Sammi Ruzzo and Katie Barrett, on top of defenders Kayleigh Koen and Abbey Deroeve. SMS also added former MIAA standouts like forward Steph LeBlanc and defender Alexis Pettinato. Goalies Erin Drew and Melanie Allen were both strong as freshmen as well.
13. Thayer
2025-26 record: 12-11-5; lost Large School quarterfinals to BB&N
The Tigers are primed to take a step after graduating just two seniors. Michael Flynn’s squad should have no problem scoring, returning high-end forwards like Maddy Call (Harvard), Lydia Kealty, Abby Macauley and Jenna Henley. Elliana Tabor and incoming Maddie Perkins could be key as well. On the back end, Thayer will rely on Shea Richardson (Middlebury), Lilly Busconi and Emery Deroeve, while goalies Madison Hayes and Coleen Wallace return.
14. New Hampton
2025-26 record: 15-16-1; lost Small School championship to Groton
In what was almost a gap year, if you will, for New Hampton, the Huskies nearly won a fourth straight Small School title, making a run as the No. 7 seed. That should serve as reason enough to never doubt a Craig Churchill team, not to mention the core of promising returners, starting with forwards Emma MacPherson (Williams) and Kiara Drake, who each had big breakouts last winter. Meanwhile, Audra Custance, Merritt Fitch and Avery Lucier are among key forwards to watch. On the back end, junior Roxie Merrick and sophomore Emilie Poirier could lead a young blue line, along with newcomer April Mombourquette. Senior Elizabeth Vincent will hold things down in net again.
BOYS PREP RANKINGS: Who leads the top 10? | Who made the Next 15?
15. Phillips Exeter
2025-26 record: 19-7-2; won Large School championship over Choate
The top of Exeter’s lineup alone makes them a contender with the likes of Paisley Meyer (Yale) and Erin Sears (Northeastern) figuring to be among the scoring leaders in prep again. Add in promising forwards like Rylie Choi, Dominique Reiher and incoming Ani Andersen. On the back end, Samantha Crowley, Olivia Lee, Camryn Wild, Eliot McCarthy, Claudia Navrat and others return with key experience from last season’s championship run. The key will be who steps up in net between senior Lily Sabol and incoming junior Jayna Bowen.
16. Deerfield
2025-26 record: 21-5-2; lost Elite 8 championship to Loomis Chaffee
The Big Green lost a bevy of big-name contributors from a group that won a Large School title in 2025 and reached the Elite 8 final in 2026. Nevertheless, interim coach Stu Wilson’s squad has pivotal returners at all three positions. Up front, Alessandra Picard is fresh off an outstanding freshman season, while senior Olivia Austen (Brown) has been a consistent producer in recent seasons. Juniors Reagan Deery and Milana Shuman are among breakout candidates to watch as well. Meanwhile, junior Nicole Sciarretta (Harvard) established herself on the blue line last season, while Gillian Herr (Union) and Amelia Healey will be relied upon as well. In the crease, Ana Makrogiannis (Middlebury) returns, while Saimi Pesola enters the mix.
17. Taft
2025-26 record: 14-10-1; lost Large School semifinals to Choate
Like St. Mark’s, Taft’s emerging young core is primed to make even more noise this winter under Shannon Turner, returning eight of their top 10 scorers. Junior Lindsey Kunzelmann will be a key piece up front once again, as will young forwards Sophie Um, Selkie Brown and Sophia Locklear. Defense and goaltending will be strengths, too. Phoebe Weisman and Kami Moors return to a blue line that is adding former MIAA standout Cam Katapodis and Frederick Gunn star Raven Bennett. Meanwhile, junior goalies Anousheh Mohebbi and Alex Tombaugh were each strong last season.
GIRLS PREP PREVIEWS: Phillips Exeter | Taft | Loomis Chaffee | Groton | Phillips Andover | Brooks
18. Governor’s
2025-26 record: 14-9-5; lost Small School quarterfinals to St. Mark’s
Governor’s graduated plenty of leadership and depth, as well as its starting goalie, but Claudia Barcomb’s squad still has its stars to rely on. Up front, Brooke Carlson has been among prep’s top scorers alongside top-line fixture Lana Hardin. Ella McDonald and Lexi Durant are impact pieces as well. On the back end, Megan Carlson gives Gov’s an elite puck-mover alongside Lauren Dockray (Assumption). Sophomore Reagan Connor could have the opportunity to take over in the crease.
19. Berkshire
2025-26 record: 10-12-2; lost Large School quarterfinals to Taft
The Bears lost some impactful forwards to graduation, but Lisa Marshall’s squad still has a strong foundation on defense and especially in net with Katie Hurley (St. Cloud State). Gabby Ogunnupe (Brown) offers a dynamic presence on the back end in addition to breakout candidates like Heather Gao and Bea Hare. Up front, juniors Mak Komanecky, Nadia Smith and Cora Davidson make up the next wave alongside senior Kendall Dobratz (Conn. College). Incoming skaters Kori Fox and Alana Paz could make an impact right away as well.
20. Choate
2025-26 record: 14-10-1; lost Large School championship to Phillips Exeter
The Wild Boars came oh-so-close to a trophy last winter, and while a slew of key players graduated, Laura Troy’s group maintains a strong blue line to go along with promising youngsters throughout the lineup. Sophia Lind (Harvard) and Juliana Iannace (Trinity) will hold down the blue line alongside Karli Charron. Lexi Berger is a key upperclassman among the forwards, while sophomore forwards Victoire Devillers, Liv Giampa and Taryn Lattanzi offer a ton of potential, as does goalie Margaux Devillers.
MAKING THE JUMP: Former girls prep stars on going from prep to college hockey
21. Brooks
2025-26 record: 7-18-1
Returning much of the same roster as last season with some key additions, Brooks has the chance to compete for a spot in the postseason in its third year under Michael Burns. Forwards Natasha Godfrey (Assumption), Cassie Ling and Shelby Buckler form a promising core alongside Isabel Previte, while Macey Bell and former MIAA standout Riley Bergeron will add key depth as newcomers. On the back end, Addy Drinkwater and Lydia Trytek are critical additions to a blue line that knows it can rely on Ella Puleo and Maeve Phinney in the crease.
22. Middlesex
2025-26 record: 9-11-2; lost Large School quarterfinals to Phillips Exeter
While the Zebras graduated their top scorer, among other key seniors, Briana Mastel’s group features strong goaltending and a slew of promising returners. Senior goalie Niamh Tobin figures to be the bedrock of Middlesex’s success again. Meanwhile, sophomore forward Libby Melly offers plenty of potential alongside junior Scarlett Gustafson and senior Alison Fiedler. There are veterans on the back end as well, like Lucy McGaraghan, Claire Bromley and Marin Gustafson.
23. Holderness
2025-26 record: 8-15-4
It may be tough sledding in the Lakes Region with the likes of St. Paul’s and New Hampton, but Bianca Moreau’s squad could be in the hunt for the postseason with a large returning cast, plus some impactful newcomers. Holderness graduated just four seniors, and leading scorer Lexi Morris could lead the way alongside key returners like Julia Lemire, Elizabeth Maher and Cali Chocko (Lake Forest). Add in productive newcomers like Adia Murphy and Kayleigh Norton, too. Carsyn Weglarz returns on the blue line, while Payton Adams could step up in the crease along with former MIAA standouts Avery Savage and Izzy Silva.
BOYS PREP PREVIEWS: Brunswick | Winchendon | Cushing | Salisbury | Kimball Union | Hotchkiss | Williston | Taft | Holderness | Phillips Exeter | Dexter Southfield | St. Paul’s
24. Lawrence Academy
2025-26 record: 5-19-1
Entering its second season in Nikki Petrich’s system, the Spartans could push for a playoff spot, as they graduated just three seniors from last season’s group. Lawrence features promising young defenders like Avery Frias and Lexi Hinck, in addition to senior Erin McGrath (University of New England). Up front, Kate Tarr (Saint Anselm), Violet Safari, Ariya Tice, Kylie Livingstone and Callan Stewart return to the mix, while former MIAA standout Abigail Gropman is a key add. There’s consistency in the crease as well with the returns of Keagan Gray and Liv Doucette (Roger Williams).
25. Westminster
2025-26 record: 6-16-3
The Martlets boast a slew of skilled returners who could guide them back to the postseason under coach Sara Ugalde. Senior forwards Bella Zapata (Stonehill) and Mya Polastry (Bowdoin) will set the pace up front along with Piper Chaisson, while Liesel Kocourek (Wesleyan) will be critical in net. On the back end, Kuylie Kim showed plenty of promise as a freshman, as did Kiera Dunas.


