St. Paul's has something to prove this season.
The Big Red nearly made a run last winter. After trailing No. 1 Nobles, 4-1, in the Elite 8 quarterfinals, No. 8 SPS fought back to force overtime before the Bulldogs prevailed.
The loss left St. Paul's wanting more.
"I think it really motivated the kids in the offseason, especially our younger kids, to really want to work hard and want to take that next step," coach Kelli Mackey said. "We're really looking at how do we get over the hump of the Elite 8 quarterfinals? I think that takes experience and kids being used to the bright lights."
SPS' core returns with that experience. Will it be enough to take the Big Red from playoff team to championship contender?
Zoomed-out view
The Big Red graduated a handful of high-end skaters, including Maggie Berleth (Manchester, Vt.; Brown), Chelsea Bell (Barre, Vt.; Middlebury) and Tess Mulkerron (Concord, N.H.; SUNY Plattsburgh).
But SPS returns a deep, talented group that is well-equipped to withstand those losses. Many of the returners were big pieces of one of the highest-scoring offenses in prep, as SPS' 128 goals were second to Nobles.
College commits dot the lineup, whether it's forwards Erin Flaherty (Boston, Mass.; Boston University), Maddy Allen (Brown) and Cadence Crowley (North Reading, Mass.; Merrimack), defender Maddy Humber (Concord, Mass.; Yale) or goalie Paige MacPhee (Hamilton).
RANKINGS: Who leads our preseason girls prep top 10?
There's also a bevy of younger skaters prepared to take a step, coming off showing plenty of promise runs as underclassmen, now that they're used to the rigors of a prep season.
At the top of that list are sophomore forward Kelsey MacPherson (Hopkinton, Mass.) and sophomore defender Malin Wilde (Shelburne, Vt.).
"They know the schedule, how to get on the bus and all of those things. Now that's not new," Mackey said. "So, how do you then do all the other really important, intangible things consistently, coming to practice every day to work really hard? I think that's going to be the difference this year."
The last few years
St. Paul's has been a mainstay in the NEPSAC playoff picture, making the postseason for 13 straight seasons.
The Big Red have made two of the last three Elite 8 tournaments, and they've won two Large School championships since 2020.
But SPS hasn't advanced beyond the quarterfinals in the last three seasons, falling to Nobles twice in the Elite 8 quarterfinals and Thayer in the Large quarterfinals in 2025.
The coach
Mackey is entering her fifth season at the helm of the program after spending the previous two as an assistant coach.
St. Paul's has been a playoff team in each of Mackey's four seasons, compiling a 73-37-7 record. The Big Red won the Large School title in 2023, Mackey's first season, and three Lakes Region titles during her tenure.
NEXT 15: Who opens the season at Nos. 11-25 in girls prep?
Mackey, a Pittsburgh, Pa., native, also serves as a coach at USA Hockey's National 15 Camp. She played prep hockey at Phillips Andover before embarking on a collegiate career at Union, where she played her freshman season, and Hamilton College.
Who will the stars be?
If the Big Red have any hope of a deep run, Flaherty will lead the charge. The senior has been a standout over three seasons with SPS, culminating in 37 points (26 goals) in 30 games last season. She's among the best all-around centers in prep and thrives in big moments.
"She was kind of the first kid I really recruited here when I took over," Mackey said. "It's been so fun to see her grow. ... She just wants to get better and wants the team to have success. She's a gamer. She's not afraid of the bright lights."
Then there's MacPherson, who instantly stepped in as an impact player in prep after standing out in the MIAA. Despite missing time with a mid-season injury, MacPherson still posted 26 points (11 goals) in 20 games, including 16 points over her final 15 games upon her return. The '10 reached USA Hockey's National 16/17 Camp this summer after making 15 Camp in 2025.
"Kelsey is probably one of the most impressive kids in the league right now," Mackey said. "She's so powerful on her skates and her ability to finish ... to have that ending as a freshman is pretty spectacular."
GIRLS PREP PREVIEWS: Phillips Exeter |Â Taft |Â Loomis Chaffee | Groton | Phillips Andover | Brooks
Another forward at the forefront is Allen. A strong, powerful scorer, the junior broke out with 17 goals and 24 points last winter. The '09 reached back-to-back 16/17 Camps.
On the blue line, Humber is coming off a 16/17 Camp nod after reaching 15 Camp in 2025. The '10 has had two productive prep seasons, including 24 points (19 assists) as a sophomore. She can drive offense from the back end.
In the crease, MacPhee had a .925 save percentage as a junior.
Breakout candidates
With as much depth as St. Paul's has throughout the lineup, there's no shortage of players who could boost their stock this season.
There are junior forwards like Demain (14 points), Crowley (16 points) and Maealie Glanzer (17 points). Meanwhile, Grace White is a dependable senior forward, coming off 11 points last winter.
"We're gonna have a ton of depth," Mackey said. "If you look at Loomis Chaffee last year, they had a lot of depth to win, and that's kind of what I've said to the kids, like, there are going to be days where our practices are harder than our games because of our depth."
Wilde handled heavy minutes on the back end as a freshman, finishing with 15 points (13 assists). Gabby Smith (Newburyport, Mass.) took a big step as a sophomore, finishing with 11 points (10 assists), while Emma Burke (Braintree, Mass.) posted seven points as a freshman.
MAKING THE JUMP: Former girls prep stars on going from prep to college hockey
In net, sophomore Julia Alessandro (Barrington, R.I.) gives SPS another strong option in net after she had a .947 save percentage last winter. The Big Red believe they'll have a chance to win every game, no matter who's in net.
"God forbid something happens, we have both of them to compete, and they're best friends and the biggest competitors," Mackey said. "For us, knowing we have two, I really do think you need two good goalies if you're gonna make a run, especially deep into the season."
Newcomers
Adding to the depth is a slew of incoming young players who have stood out on the club circuit.
Hillary Krayer (Concord, Mass.), a '12 forward, is a quick skater who has impressed with Assabet's 14U squad. Meanwhile, Caroline Warrington (Hanover, N.H.), an '11 Valley Junior Warriors product, as well as 16U Assabet forwards Abigael Morrissette and Chatham Brouillette (St. Albans, Vt.), are also entering the mix.
On defense, '11Â Ava Franus could be a factor, too, after a strong fall with the 16U East Coast Wizards.
All are freshmen, save for Brouillette, a sophomore, a former Vermont high school standout with Bellows Free Academy-St. Albans.
SPS is eager to add Franus (5-foot-10) and Morrissette's (5-foot-11) size to the lineup, too.
The ceiling
With all the talk of depth and offensive punch, the Big Red's potential is high.
But to take the next step into becoming a true title contender, Mackey believes it comes down to the details.
BOYS PREP RANKINGS: Who leads the top 10? | Who made the Next 15?
"We have the skill, so are we ready to do the little things? Is everyone willing to buy into their role on the team?" she said. "Are we ready to compete like crazy and do the little things of blocking shots, bearing down on pucks on power plays and stuff like that to get us over the hump?"


