It was around 10 p.m. on Feb. 12, 2025.
Northfield Mount Hermon had taken down its local rival, Williston Northampton, 7-5, earlier in the day when second-year NMH head coach Jake Bennett's phone rang. It was head of school, Brian Hargrove.
The rink was on fire.
A spark from the heater in the NMH locker room hit propane, and the locker room ignited. It snowed that night, too, and the roof caved in.
Thankfully, nobody was in the locker room at the time. But all of the varsity boys hockey team's equipment was in there. Everything was destroyed.
Seven games remained in the season, including the next matchup against Winchendon the following Monday. Sure, the rink was an issue. But the kids were now left without equipment, too. Northfield Mount Hermon responded by essentially giving Bennett a blank check to get new equipment.
"I was texting everyone in the hockey world," Bennett said. "I was trying to put together pants, gloves — whatever I could find to get us back on the ice."
Bennett stumbled into some luck. When he called TSR Hockey in Exeter, N.H., the company was in a meeting with top executives at Bauer.
MASS. STATE CHAMPS: Masters Academy wins 15O | River Rats wins 16U | Central Mass. Penguins wins 18U
Bauer heard about it and sent a clear message: "We can do everything."
That Friday, NMH players boarded buses for the TSR store. Every player was outfitted head to toe with new gear. Come Monday, NMH took down Winchendon, 4-3, in overtime.
With the equipment settled, a bigger order of business came next: the rink.
"It was time," Bennett said. "We were so overdue for a hockey rink because our old one was falling apart."
Northfield Mount Hermon's McCollum Arena had always been a bit of a running joke in prep circles. In 2025, it was 58 years old and an open-air rink.
Yes, it got really, really cold inside. Sometimes, it was so cold that it was unsafe, and NMH would give up home games to play elsewhere.
But there were worse side effects.
The water tank wasn't big enough to support resurfacing the ice as many times as they needed to in a day. They were without power some days. And even when they did have power, there sometimes wasn't enough for the brand new Zamboni.
The pipes would freeze when temperatures went into the teens and below. When Avon Old Farms played at NMH, legendary Winged Beavers head coach John Gardner would have his backup goalie sit in the bathroom to stay warm in case he had to go in.
"The bathrooms were hit or miss," Bennett said.
It took two or more weeks to put the ice down, preventing the team from skating on campus for the first two weeks of the year. And there were hiccups along the way, like the compressor shutting off, that extended the process.
READ MORE: Why fall hockey felt so different this year and what's to come
The new rink was greenlit in January 2024 and was slated to finish by November 2025. But setbacks, such as back orders on electrical equipment, pushed the project further down the calendar.
The fire, however, was the final straw. Come May 2025, the school broke ground on "The Ice Barn" — a new rink with modern technology, big locker rooms and, above all else, exterior walls. Kate Barber and Ed Pitoniak were the lead donors for the new rink.
"The new rink means the world to the hockey programs," NMH girls head coach Brianna Wood said in 2025. "It's more than just a building to us — it's a symbol of belief in the hockey programs and everything we are working towards."
Since arriving at NMH as boys head coach in the summer of 2023, Bennett has had arguably the toughest hand dealt to him in prep.
He took over after Matt Harlow, hired that spring, left to work for the New York Rangers. Harlow had been taking over for Kevin Czepiel, who left NMH for Berkshire. Much of Czepiel's 2022-23 team were seniors, and many of those who weren't left for Berkshire with their coach.
Harlow brought in a batch of players over the summer. So when Bennett inherited the team, they weren't his guys.
And even when he began recruiting for future seasons, there was always the elephant in the room: the rink.
"It was for sure a challenge, largely in part due to the facility and just compared to the marketplace," Bennett said. "Think about our little pocket in New England. We were the only ones that didn't have ice down on moving day. We had a great thing where the kids skated three to four days a week at a local rink down the street, but they still had to get on a bus to do it.
"You could go 15 minutes south to Deerfield and have a completely different experience. Or even 30 minutes south to Williston and just have a different quality of life."
Bennett knew this would be a challenge during his time at NMH, so he mapped out a five-year plan from when he was hired.
Five years for the rink to be done, and five years to set the rosters the way he wanted them, with players spread out across birth years and graduations.
After going 8-23-1 in his first year and 15-15-1 in 2024-25, Bennett's team is coming off a four-win season last winter.
POWER RANKINGS: Our preseason top 10 | Our preseason Next 15
It's still a process. NMH's recruiting class was better this offseason. And with the Hoggers set to play in the new rink this winter, the wins should build on themselves.
"As the new facility was coming, you knew you were going to have a better track record of getting younger kids who were like, 'I want to play there a year from now'," Bennett said. "They were okay putting up with the outdoor rink for a year.
"We obviously hope and feel we're going to be better."


