Dexter Southfield was hosting the Prep Alliance Showcase on Oct. 24 and 25. It was a smorgasbord of prep teams playing together in the fall, and three teams — the Cape Cod Whalers, Boston Junior Eagles and the East Coast Wizards — featured players from multiple prep and high school teams.
Early that Sunday morning, the Central Mass. Penguins (Cushing) hit the ice against the Boston Junior Eagles.
This would've been a must-see matchup in years past. The Junior Eagles have always had some of the best Metro Boston talent in prep at the 18U and 16U levels. They won the Mass. state championship at both levels last fall. The fall before, the Junior Eagles were in the 15O, 16U and 18U Mass. state title games, winning at the 15s and 18s level.
But on this particular Sunday, the Central Mass. Penguins had their way, making it 6-0 early in the third period. To their credit, the Junior Eagles scored four as the third period wore on, but the game was never in doubt.
Is this a one-game anomaly? It could be — but it likely isn't.
Instead, it's indicative of where fall hockey is going at the 18U and 16U levels. Over the last few years, more prep schools are opting for their players to suit up on one team during the fall.
The Junior Eagles are a prime example. Sixteen of its 17 rostered players from its 18U team in 2025-26 graduated or left early for junior hockey. This year's 18U team had a mix of '08s, '09s and '10s, as the Junior Eagles didn't have a Tier 1 16U team.
Many from the Junior Eagles' 16U team from last season would've moved up and filled spots on the 18U squad, but they didn't because of this change in the landscape.
Keith Olympia (Sudbury, Mass.) left the Junior Eagles to play on the Minuteman Flames 18U team, which was St. Mark's fall team. Defensemen Ryder Bisson (Holden, Mass.) and Kellen Labanara (Canton, Mass.) both played on Dexter Southfield's Brookline Whalers fall squad. Goalie Max Levine-Stein (Salem, Mass.) opted for Pingree's team in the New England Fall Prep Hockey League.
And forwards Danny Patch (Melrose, Mass.) and Ryan Elrick (Canton, Mass.) both transferred to Cushing, opting to play for that Penguins team that won on that Sunday.
This isn't fully a Junior Eagles problem. It's not their fault they have high-end talent that leaves early for junior hockey.
It's just the way fall hockey is trending.
The Northern Conn. Nor'Easter (seven D1 commits), Neponset Valley River Rats (five), Yale Junior Bulldogs (two) and Mid Fairfield (one) were the only other local 18U teams not associated with one prep school with Division 1 commits on their rosters.
BOYS PREP PREVIEWS: Brunswick | Winchendon | Cushing | Salisbury | Kimball Union | Hotchkiss | Williston | Taft | Holderness | Phillips Exeter | Dexter Southfield | St. Paul’s | Nobles | Frederick Gunn | Kent
There are, however, some caveats. The Nor'Easter were mostly Avon Old Farms players with a handful from Salisbury, Deerfield, Trinity-Pawling and Millbrook.
Salisbury and Deerfield both have teams in the CEM Fall League, while Trinity-Pawling played as the Hartford Junior Wolfpack this fall. Whether a couple of players continue to opt to play on teams that aren't their prep team in the fall is unknown. Many players grow up playing for teams like Mid Fairfield (which was mostly Brunswick players this fall) and want to remain loyal.
But if history is any guide, it's doubtful.
The River Rats recruit well for their 18U team and do a pretty good job of keeping talent that doesn't move on to juniors. Their team featured players from schools like Williston Northampton, Phillips Andover, Tabor, Belmont Hill, Governor's Academy, Lawrence Academy and Salisbury.
But the River Rats also understand where the fall landscape is headed. Along with two 19U showcase teams full of players from multiple places, they offered an 18U Tier 2 team for all BC High players and another 19U-level team for Phillips Exeter's squad.
So, what's next?
More prep teams will want their teams to play together in the fall. The CEM Fall League started last fall with six prominent prep schools — Salisbury, Frederick Gunn, Westminster, Canterbury, Taft and Deerfield — and there's always buzz about expansion. Leagues like the NEFPHL and Peak Performance Prep have had certain prep schools playing together for a few falls in a row, and are expanding, too.
Playing on a fall team with different players certainly has its benefits. But playing games and practicing with your prep team in the fall is just easier and more streamlined. When I talk to prep coaches whose teams play together in the fall, they mention families like it a lot more.
"It's something families are actually really excited about when you talk to them about it," Frederick Gunn head coach Craig Badger said to me recently.
MASS. STATE CHAMPS: Masters Academy wins 15O | River Rats wins 16U | Central Mass. Penguins wins 18U
Kimball Union head coach Tim Whitehead always mentions safety in getting to games. KUA provides buses to transport players to fall games. There's no need for players to set up rides and have 17- and 18-year-olds drive two-plus hours to games and back from Meriden, N.H.
That is undoubtedly a selling point for recruits.
And that's just the 18U level. The 16U level is a whole different thing. It's nothing new that the top 15O players get picked off for the U.S. National Team Development Program. And then a few others might be taken by QMJHL teams or tendered by USHL squads.
But a common new thought is that if a 15O player played prep, why should they go back to playing against their birth year in the fall at the 16U level? Why not continue playing older players and opt for the 18U level? This is precisely where prep teams playing together in the fall come in.
There's also the new USA Hockey Development League, with 15U and 17U levels. No one knows how that will roll out, but it's likely that it pulls some players from these typical fall teams, as well as some preps.
Which brings me to this.
After the River Rats edged out the Cape Cod Whalers, 3-2, for the 16U Mass. state tournament on Sunday, I wrote that the River Rats might be the last stacked 16U team in New England.
That River Rats team was full of top players in prep. They were the most talented 16U squad in the region. Most of the players on that team came from prep schools that don't have fall squads — the perfect storm to keep them together.
Several of those 16U players won't play for the 18U River Rats next season due to moving on to junior hockey. If things keep changing, maybe some of those players opt for their prep school's fall team.
But even deeper than that, 16U hockey will keep taking hits, too, as more players opt to play for their prep school's fall team.
That's why Sunday's Tier 1 18U Mass. state championship was so symbolic. Those Central Mass. Penguins took on Holderness' fall team, Islanders Hockey Club West. There were nine '10s in the game. That's nine talented players who normally would've been at the 16U level who weren't.
And that was in one game.
POWER RANKINGS: Our preseason top 10 | Our preseason Next 15
At one point, a group of players from another team gathered at the table next to mine and were watching the 18U final. A few of them wondered who was playing.
"It's Cushing vs. Holderness," one of them said. "It's basically a prep championship."
Get used to it.


